Although lock opposed permanent tariffs, politics expedience despite sound business economics prompted the starting Fathers to pass the first U.S. Tariff act. Because that 72 years, northern special interest groups used these protective tariffs to exploit the south for their own benefit. Ultimately in 1861, the oppression of those income duties started the civil War.

You are watching: Why did the north favor protective tariffs and the south oppose them


In enhancement to generating revenue, a tariff hurts the capacity of foreigners to sell in domestic markets. One affordable or high-quality foreign good is dangerous competition for an expensive or low-quality residential one. However when a tariff bumps up the price the the foreign good, it provides the domestic one a price advantage. The rate of the tariff varies by industry.


If the tariff is high enough, even an inefficient domestic firm can compete with a vastly superior international company. The is the industry’s consumers who ultimately pay this tax and also the industry’s producer who advantage in profits.


As beforehand as the Revolutionary War, the south primarily created cotton, rice, sugar, indigo and tobacco. The phibìc purchased these raw materials and also turned them right into manufactured goods. Through 1828, foreign manufactured goods confronted high import taxes. Foreign raw materials, however, were free of tariffs.


Thus the residential manufacturing industries of the phibìc benefited twice, as soon as as the producers enjoying the protection of high manufacturing tariffs and once together consumers with a free raw materials market. The life materials industries of the south were left to struggle versus foreign competition.


Because manufactured goods were not created in the South, they had to one of two people be imported or shipped down from the North. Either way, a huge expense, it is in it shipping fees or the commonwealth tariff, was included to the price the manufactured items only because that Southerners. Because importation was regularly cheaper than shipping indigenous the North, the southern paid most of the federal tariffs.


Much that the tariff revenue accumulated from southerly consumers was used to construct railroads and also canals in the North. In between 1830 and 1850, 30,000 mile of track to be laid. At their best, this tracks services the North. Many rail lines had actually no financial effect in ~ all. Countless of the schemes come lay monitor were simply a way to acquire government subsidies. Fraud and corruption were rampant.


With many of the tariff revenue built up in the South and also then spent in the North, the southern rightly felt exploited. At the time, 90 percent that the commonwealth government’s annual revenue come from these taxes ~ above imports.


Historians Paul Collier and Anke Hoeffer discovered that a few common determinants increase the likelihood that secession in a region: reduced wages, an economy based on raw materials and also external exploitation. Although popular movies emphasize slavery as a cause of the polite War, the war finest fits a psycho-historical model of the southern rebelling versus Northern exploitation.


Many Americans perform not know this fact. A non-slave-owning Southern seller angered over yet another proposed tariff act does not make a compelling scene in a movie. However, that would certainly be closer come the original cause of the Civil war than any kind of scene of slaves picking cotton.


Slavery was in reality on the wane. Slaves visiting England were free, according to the court in 1569. France, Russia, Spain and also Portugal had actually outlawed slavery. Slavery had actually been abolished anywhere in the British empire 27 year earlier, many thanks to wilhelm Wilberforce. In the united States, the move of slaves had actually been outlawed 53 years earlier by cutting board Jefferson in the plot Prohibiting the income of servants (1807) and the Abolition the the servant Trade act in England (1807). Enslavement was a dying and repugnant institution.


The rewritten background of the polite War began with Lincoln together a brilliant political tactic come rally public opinion. The worry of slavery provided sentimental leverage, whereas oppressing the south with hurtful tariffs go not. Outrage versus the greater evil that slavery offered to mask the financial harm the North was doing to the South.


The instance in the South might be likened to having actually a legit legal case however losing the support of the jury once testimony concerning the defendant"s moral failings was admitted right into the court proceedings.


Toward the end of the war, Lincoln make the problem primarily about the continuation of slavery. By doing so, he successfully silenced the debate about economic issues and states’ rights. The main grievance the the Southern states was tariffs. Although enslavement was a variable at the outset that the polite War, it was no the single or even primary cause.


The tariff of 1828, referred to as the Tariff the Abominations in the South, to be the worst exploitation. The passed conference 105 come 94 but lost among Southern congressmen 50 come three. The South argued that favoring some markets over others to be unconstitutional.


The southern Carolina Exposition and Protest composed by evil President man Calhoun warned that if the tariff the 1828 were not repealed, southern Carolina would secede. It cited Jefferson and Madison for the criterion that a state had the appropriate to disapprove or nullify commonwealth law.


In one 1832 state legislature project speech, Lincoln characterized his position, saying, “My national politics are short and sweet, favor the old woman’s dance. Ns am in favor of a national bank ... In donate of the internal improvements system and a high protective tariff.’ He was firmly against cost-free trade and in donate of making use of the power of the federal government to benefit details industries such together Lincoln’s favorite, Pennsylvania steel.


The nation experienced a period of lower tariffs and vibrant economic growth from 1846 to 1857. Then a bank failure brought about the scare of 1857. Congress offered this case to begin discussing a new tariff act, later dubbed the morrill Tariff that 1861. However, those arguments were met v such southern hostility the the south seceded prior to the act to be passed.


The south did not secede primarily due to the fact that of slavery. In Lincoln’s first Inaugural Address, that promised he had no intention to readjust slavery in the South. He said it would certainly be unconstitutional for him to execute so. But he promised he would certainly invade any state that failed to collect tariffs in order come enforce them. The declare was received from Baltimore come Charleston together a explanation of battle on the South.


Slavery to be an abhorrent practice. It might have to be the reason that rallied the north to win. But it was no the main reason why the southern seceded. The Civil battle began because of an increasing push to ar protective tariffs favoring Northern business interests and every Southern family members paid the price.

See more: How Far Is Chicago Illinois From Indianapolis Indiana Polis To Chicago


David man Marotta is president of Marotta Wealth management Inc. Of Charlottesville. College of Virginia graduate Megan Russell, solution analyst for the company, likewise contributed to this commentary. Questions must be sent to emarotta.com or Marotta Wealth monitoring Inc., One town Green Circle, Suite 100, Charlottesville, Va. 22903-4619.


capture the latest in Opinion

Get opinion pieces, letters and also editorials sent directly to your inbox weekly!


* ns understand and agree that registration on or usage of this site constitutes agreement to that user agreement and also privacy policy.

Editor’s Note: together the nation prepares to observe Veterans day on Thursday, Nov. 11, The everyday Progress uses this comment from a regional U.S…


*