What have you had actually for dinner?vs.What walk you have for dinner?vs.What you had for dinner?

Which sentence is correct i wonder?

Thanks.

You are watching: What did you had for dinner


Not lot at every really. They are largely interchangeable.

‘What did girlfriend have…’ have the right to be used more from the occasion (eating dinner) than ‘what have actually you had…’ which requirements to be asked sensibly soon after the meal.


*
Rickyrocky:

Hi,

What have you had for dinner? Correct.vs.What did you have actually for dinner? no correct there is no the context necessary or a definite adverb of time.

Which sentence is correct, ns wonder?

Thanks.

Thanks


I think that the “expiration time” because that ´have had´ come transform into “did have” is precisely as quickly as you have ingested the meal you had.

*
That´s where the grammar connects come the peristalsis! Is the right?
*


No, it’s not that immediate., particularly if a time referral is given (eg. What have you had for dinner today?)


What go you have actually for dinner? Is much more common since it is shorter.

What have you had actually for dinner? is stronger and also sometimes supplied to asking if if who is taking treatment of lock self.


Hi,

This question pertains to the fundamental difference between the past simple and the prsent perfect. This has nothing to carry out with one being ‘more common’ or ‘stronger’ 보다 the other. What did you have? relates to a time in the past not concerned now and can be overtly stated by pointing out that time through for instance an adverb or simply hinting at a previous time. What have you had? web links the past to now by referring to a previous time yet connecting the to what you room saying/writing now.

Alan


Hi Alan,

“links the past to currently by referring to a past time however ‘connecting’ the to what you are saying/writing now.”

I have a question concerning your explanation above. For those of united state who don’t usage rememberingsomer.com together our major language, at times, that pretty tough to identify the consumption of the an easy past and the existing perfect. Words ‘connecting’ is fairly vague come me whenever i read around it in part grammar book explaining around the current perfect tense.

We space told to usage the simple past once we room referring to the past.However, we space told to usage the existing perfect when we space talking around an event which occurred in the past but has some connection to what we space saying/writing now.

Let me give a similar example to mine initial question:

What have you seen?vs.What did friend see?

Sometimes, together a non-native speaker, i really to be confused regarding which to use.Maybe we require some sort of paper definition to really recognize the subtle distinctions of this tenses.

Thanks a lot. )


Alan January 14, 2011, 9:23am #15

Hi Rickyrocky,

I evaluate that it is an overwhelming to distinguish one native another. Permit me begin with another example. Imagine the the police are trying to find someone in link with a crime. Castle would put a picture of the guy on a an alert board and the words would certainly be:

Have you watched this man? The concern is not about ‘when’ but around ‘seeing’ and also whether anyone has seen the man in a duration from part time in the previous up till currently - in other words ‘so far’.

The police could additionally put a picture of the man and ask this question: did you watch this guy on Friday January first between 10 pm and 11.30 pm? The question this time is around when.

Hope this little example help a bit.

Alan


1 choose
E2e4 January 14, 2011, 10:40am #16
*
Alan:

Hi Rickyrocky,

Have you seen this man? The inquiry is not about ‘when’ but about ‘seeing’ and whether anyone has actually seen the guy in a period from part time in the past up till currently - in various other words ‘so far’.

See more: Is A Fish A Carnivore, Herbivore Or Omnivore, What Percentage Of Fish Are Herbivorous Vs

The police could additionally put a picture of the man and also ask this question: go you watch this male on Friday January first between 10 pm and also 11.30 pm? The question this time is about when.Hope this tiny example helps a bit.

Alan

YEP!

Thanks

…and whether anyone has actually seen the male in a duration since (from) some time in the past. (up till currently - in various other words ‘so far’.) (wink, smile)


Rickyrocky January 14, 2011, 2:54pm #17

Yup, that helps. Thanks!


home Categories FAQ/Guidelines terms of service Privacy plan

Powered by Discourse, finest viewed through JavaScript enabled