Quick bring away on Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi and also time-permitting, a Western. Don't wait for the Western.

You are watching: The curious case of edgar witherspoon


Main menu

The curious instance I got was a curious situation of deja vu earlier to the fads episode of Night Visions. In the post, I had a paragraph stating how each action of the plot was evident from the start:

Of food Martin’s OCD tics are going to be the glue the keeps the world together. Of course Critchley is walk to be skeptical. Of food Martin is going to be discovered to it is in telling the truth. And of food Critchley will inherit the burden the he was doubtful of.

Change the names, and this is precisely the same story. The is not necessarily a negative thing. Ns guess it is a wide enough trope, choose time-travel, that no one can insurance claim to own it. And I am a sucker because that this specific trope, so instance dismissed. I provide it a Trumpian pardon — maybe not deserved, yet who’s walk to stop me?

I deleted around 500 words over that just seemed superfluous; although beautiful composed. Take care of Morgan play Edgar Witherspoon perfectly. As a young man — or at least as young together Harry Morgan ever was — he was a little bit of a stiff. The laughs he got earlier then appeared to it is in from hamming it increase or because of funny words coming out of his Dragnet facade. In this episode, he seems to have actually arrived at top coot-hood. The is a funny old guy, believably sincere v his krazee ideas. Unfortunately — and also I’m walking to usage that word a lot — the psychiatrist appears to be in a various episode, and also the remainder of the cast are just non-entities.

See more: What Do You Do If You Accidentally Touch Your Elf On The Shelf


Unfortunately # 2: This is the first episode the the third season (although the 4th episode top top the DVD?) and also the first appearance the Robin Ward as the announcer. Ns was often vital of Charles Aidman’s avuncular voice undermining many episodes, therefore a readjust was welcome. I’m not certain this is an improvement, though. Native one outing, the strikes me as if the is trying come emulate both Aidman and Rod Serling. Ns hear shades of castle both in his delivery.

Unfortunately # 3: The score, together is generally the case, is just completely inappropriate. Harry Morgan to be fine being eccentric, but I would fairly have had actually the score present a little much more seriousness. This scores too regularly cheapen the stakes through musical flourishes and little pixie dust sounds. The psychiatrist’s performance was grimly at odds through the remainder of the episode, yet maybe he to be closest to getting it right. The island the Tuatau was destroyed by a tidal tide for cryin’ the end loud! do you have no feeling atoll — heyooooo! <1>